There is some kind of magic, some kind of dark matter, not seen, but ever present, in the script and music of The Fantasticks, a musical with a story and characters that keep traveling across generations. Ruskin Group Theatre brings back the enchantment and humor of this pastoral image of America.
With Danny Bernardo‘s endearing voice, the character El Gallo sings “Try to Remember”, opening up a story that shows the naive vision of love and the harsh realities of life. Based on writer/director Scott Miller’s analysis, the story of The Fantasticks is an evolution of Aucassin and Nicolette, a medieval chantefable from the 12th or 13th century. It contains universal themes that connect with the audience in perplexing ways. The show has been staged multiple times around the world with impressive success.
In Elina de Santos‘ production, the characters capture the illusions of the young and the stubbornness of the old, with the complex layers of El Gallo, the mysterious and alluring bandido. De Santos builds a universe of innocence, trickery, and mythical search for happiness. Her characters experience the profound transformation implied in the script, aligning the characters to serve the story and complete the cycle. She does that without sacrificing the comical element in this musical. The humor and oddity is mainly projected by Michael Redfield as Mortimer and John Wuchte as Henry. These two extraordinary actors mesmerize and engage with their performance, adding a topsy-turvy and exciting vibe to the story.
As for El Gallo, Bernardo plays his character with an attractive aura of mystery, temptation, and wicked wisdom that reminds us of the duality of good and evil, a concept that dates back to the beginning of human history. The innocence, of course, relies on Pollono as Luisa, and Hemingway as Matt. With all of their youth in full display, they execute a lively performance that translates the dreams and the naiveness implied in their roles. They have more experience to gain, but they’re on their way to new heights.
De Santos uses her creativity to highlight the figures of speech that give depth to the story. The moonlight, hiding the shortcomings, and the sun, exposing them, are devices used effectively to transmit the message clearly. De Santos also excels in building the myth of Luisa and Matt. She progresses the scenes to show their longings for something more than the immediate environment in which they live, eager to explore the world laid out before their eyes. The transformation experienced through their growth and wisdom achieved through their travels and pain, is cleverly displayed in the last scenes. It’s implicit in the play, sometimes it is necessary to get hurt to unlock true love. Both Luisa and Matt get to understand this passage of life, and just like in Aucassin and Nicolette, their love only grows stronger as they are apart from each other.
To close the cycle, El Gallo leads the ensemble to sing “Try to Remember”, an invitation to go back to our childhood, to the excitement of our idealistic dreams, a return to innocence. The audience accepted the invitation.
The Fantasticks
Ruskin Group Theatre
3000 Airport Avenue
Santa Monica, CA 90405
July 18, 2025 – August 24, 2025
8pm on Fridays, Saturdays; 2pm Sundays
Tickets: ruskingrouptheatre.com
Book and lyrics by Tom Jones
Music by Harvey Schmidt
Directed by Elina de Santos
Musical Direction by Michael Redfield
Presented by Ruskin Group Theatre
Cast: Michael D. Cohen as Bellomy, Danny Bernardo as Narrator/El Gallo, Rhett Hemingway as Matt, Kiel Kennedy as Hucklebee, Sophie Pollono as Luisa, Michael Redfield as Mortimer, Raven Scott as Mute, John Wuchte as Henry, Silas Shultz as Understudy/Matt.
Creative team: Bruce Goodrich (Scenic Design), Michael Redfield (Sound Design/Music Director), Matt Richter (Lighting Design), Jennifer Oundjian (Choreographer), Erik Hall (Co-choreographer), Victoria Hoffman (Casting), John Ruskin (Artistic Director/Producer), Michael Myers (Producing Artistic Director), Nicole Millar (Production Stage Manager).
